New Lexington, OH Pizza on Carroll Street
Perry County Pizza in New Lexington
From Carroll Street in New Lexington, we bake pizza, subs and wings for Perry County families every day.
- 4.0146 Google reviews
- Open dailyToday's hours
- (740) 343-0405Call to order
Visit Us
Proudly serving
- New Lexington
- Somerset
- Junction City
- Crooksville
- Shawnee
Hours
- Mon - Fri10:30am - 10pm
- Sat12pm - 10:30pm
- Sun12pm - 9:30pm

Pizza
Check out our traditional and specialty pizzas!

Subs
View our great selection of delicious subs!

Wings & Sides
Check out all of our wings and available sides!

Calzones & Strombolis
Unlike the rest, we only make the best!

Dinners
Enjoy hot dinners with a side of garlic bread!

Salads
Try one of our fresh, made-to-order salads!

Creno's New Lexington
A Perry County Favorite
Near downtown and the Perry County Courthouse, our shop serves New Lexington Panthers fans, county workers and families looking for a fresh, homemade meal. With State Route 13 and State Route 37 close by, Somerset, Junction City, Crooksville and Shawnee neighbors order online and pick up fast.
What makes the difference
- Dough made fresh every morning, never frozen
- Homemade pizza and spaghetti sauce
- Proprietary cheeses and meats
- Over 45 years of pizza tradition
- Address
- 787 Carroll St, New Lexington, Ohio, 43764
- Service Area
- New Lexington, Somerset, Junction City, Crooksville, Shawnee
- Nearby
- Downtown New Lexington and the Perry County Courthouse
- Access
- Carroll Street with State Route 13 and State Route 37 close by
- Closer options
- Bremen and Rushville neighbors may be closer to our Mulberry St shop; Zanesville, to Maysville Ave
What Neighbors Are Saying
- Allen “Outlawnomad” Carper
2 weeks ago
What are the calzones? Only place in the area that has them so far that I've noticed. Was excellent, cooked to perfection, great service.
- Serena Stoneburner
2 months ago
Private owned. Well cared for and clean. Best service, great people. The food was hot and plenty of toppings. Top 10 in New Lexington Ohio.
Reviews from Google
Start a Franchise
Are you ready to start your own successful business? Look no further than Creno's Pizza franchise! With a proven track record of pizza restaurants and corporate support, you can bring the taste of delicious, authentic pizza to your community while building a fantastic career.
Learn More
