Pizza Near the Lake in Buckeye Lake, OH
Lake Day Pizza in Buckeye Lake
On Hebron Road just off the water, we feed boaters, campers and year-round lake families with pizzas and subs that travel well.
- 4.2232 Google reviews
- Open dailyToday's hours
- (740) 928-2300Call to order
Visit Us
Proudly serving
- Buckeye Lake
- Hebron
- Millersport
- Thornville
- Kirkersville
Hours
- Mon - Thu10am - 9:30pm
- Fri10am - 10pm
- Sat12pm - 10pm
- Sun3pm - 9:30pm

Pizza
Check out our traditional and specialty pizzas!

Subs
View our great selection of delicious subs!

Wings & Sides
Check out all of our wings and available sides!

Calzones & Strombolis
Unlike the rest, we only make the best!

Dinners
Enjoy hot dinners with a side of garlic bread!

Salads
Try one of our fresh, made-to-order salads!

Creno's Buckeye Lake
Your Stop On and Off the Water
After a day at Buckeye Lake State Park or the North Shore, grab a hot pizza without the long drive into town. Our dough is made fresh every morning for a crisp, chewy crust. We sit minutes from Interstate 70 and State Route 79, convenient for Hebron, Millersport, Thornville and Kirkersville. Order ahead online for a quick pickup.
What makes the difference
- Dough made fresh every morning, never frozen
- Homemade pizza and spaghetti sauce
- Proprietary cheeses and meats
- Over 45 years of pizza tradition
- Address
- 11184 Hebron Rd., Buckeye Lake, Ohio, 43008
- Service Area
- Buckeye Lake, Hebron, Millersport, Thornville, Kirkersville
- Nearby
- Buckeye Lake State Park, the North Shore and the lake marinas
- Access
- State Route 79 (Hebron Road), minutes from Interstate 70
- Closer options
- Heath and south Newark may be closer to Heath on Hebron Rd; Baltimore, to our Main Street shop
What Neighbors Are Saying
- Andi Gainer
2 months ago
The person taking my order was very friendly and professional. He won the extra mile to be sure to let me know there was a parade ready to start and then I may want to leave a little early to pick up my order or take a different route to the store. As always my pizza was perfect! Even though there are other stores closer to us my husband and I will travel the extra distance for this store in the store only. Definitely worth it. Very satisfied.
- Keenan Cumberland
3 months ago
My favorite thing at Keno's is their Philly steak sub. Since I don't eat pork, it's hard for me to eat pizza unless it's just cheese or with chicken and vegetables. I wish there would be a a restaurant that would offer turkey pepperoni. I think that would get a lot more business than they think they would. There's several of us out here who don't eat pork. Just a kind suggestion
- Carla H
a month ago
The pizza and cheese bread were hot and delicious! The big cookie was a hit with the grandkids. Friendly and efficient employees!
Reviews from Google
Start a Franchise
Are you ready to start your own successful business? Look no further than Creno's Pizza franchise! With a proven track record of pizza restaurants and corporate support, you can bring the taste of delicious, authentic pizza to your community while building a fantastic career.
Learn More
