Johnstown, OH Pizza on West Coshocton Street
Johnstown's Neighborhood Pizza
On West Coshocton Street, we serve Johnstown and the growing western Licking County community with homemade pizza, subs and more.
- 4.0172 Google reviews
- Open dailyToday's hours
- (740) 966-0123Call to order
Visit Us
Proudly serving
- Johnstown
- Alexandria
- Croton
- Homer
- New Albany area
Hours
- Mon - Thu10:30am - 10pm
- Fri10:30am - 10:30pm
- Sat12pm - 10:30pm
- Sun2pm - 9pm

Pizza
Check out our traditional and specialty pizzas!

Subs
View our great selection of delicious subs!

Wings & Sides
Check out all of our wings and available sides!

Calzones & Strombolis
Unlike the rest, we only make the best!

Dinners
Enjoy hot dinners with a side of garlic bread!

Salads
Try one of our fresh, made-to-order salads!

Creno's Johnstown
Rooted in Johnstown
From Johnstown-Monroe Johnnies games to weekend family nights, our shop keeps the small-town feel with dough made fresh every morning. Neighbors along State Route 37 and US Route 62, including Alexandria, Croton, Homer and the new homes toward New Albany, order online and pick up in Johnstown.
What makes the difference
- Dough made fresh every morning, never frozen
- Homemade pizza and spaghetti sauce
- Proprietary cheeses and meats
- Over 45 years of pizza tradition
- Address
- 705 W Coshocton St., Johnstown, Ohio, 43031
- Service Area
- Johnstown, Alexandria, Croton, Homer, New Albany area
- Nearby
- The Johnstown village center and Johnstown-Monroe schools
- Access
- US Route 62 (West Coshocton Street) and State Route 37
- Closer options
- Granville and north Newark neighbors may be closer to Log Pond Dr; Pataskala, to Columbia Rd
What Neighbors Are Saying
- Tyler Mautz
2 years ago
I wanted to give it two tries before I posted a review because every pizza shop goes through its high and lows. As a person who grew up on the OG Crenos in Zanesville, this place has lived up to the expectations. Pizza is great, as always, but if you like a crispy crust, get it well done. This is something I do most places these days, though. But the main point is the Italian sub. It’s so simple but so balanced. I don’t know how else to explain it, it’s just very good. I’ve been to several different crenos locations, some that have not made it for whatever reason. So bravo to the manager of this store.
- Robert Sanstra
a month ago
Ordered a meats stromboli, it was fresh, hot and tasty!
- Dave Johnson
a year ago
First time having Creno's!! Staff was great. Greeted me as soon as I came in the door. Pizza was ready on time. Pizza was hot and delicious!! I'll definitely be back next time I'm in the area. 🙌
- Cole Austin
2 months ago
It feels so kind toward me, and I consider it the best. I appreciate the food, which conveys genuine care; it recognizes autism, and I value them.
Reviews from Google
Start a Franchise
Are you ready to start your own successful business? Look no further than Creno's Pizza franchise! With a proven track record of pizza restaurants and corporate support, you can bring the taste of delicious, authentic pizza to your community while building a fantastic career.
Learn More
