Fresh Pizza on Main Street in Baltimore, OH
Baltimore's Hometown Pizza Shop
Right on North Main Street in the heart of the village, we bake hand-tossed pizzas, toasted subs and wings for Baltimore families every day.
- 4.392 Google reviews
- Open dailyToday's hours
- (740) 400-4102Call to order
Visit Us
Proudly serving
- Baltimore
- Basil
- Millersport
- Thurston
- Pleasantville
Hours
- Mon - Fri11am - 9:30pm
- Sat12pm - 9:30pm
- Sun3pm - 9pm

Pizza
Check out our traditional and specialty pizzas!

Subs
View our great selection of delicious subs!

Wings & Sides
Check out all of our wings and available sides!

Calzones & Strombolis
Unlike the rest, we only make the best!

Dinners
Enjoy hot dinners with a side of garlic bread!

Salads
Try one of our fresh, made-to-order salads!

Creno's Baltimore
A Village Main Street Favorite
Our Baltimore shop sits steps from the village center, an easy stop on the way home from Liberty Union schools or a Friday night ballgame. Dough is made fresh every morning, never frozen. Families from Basil, Millersport, Thurston and the farms along State Route 158 make the short drive into town. Order ahead online and your pizza is ready when you pull up.
What makes the difference
- Dough made fresh every morning, never frozen
- Homemade pizza and spaghetti sauce
- Proprietary cheeses and meats
- Over 45 years of pizza tradition
- Address
- 107 N Main St., Baltimore, Ohio, 43105
- Service Area
- Baltimore, Basil, Millersport, Thurston, Pleasantville
- Nearby
- The village center on North Main Street and Liberty Union schools
- Access
- State Route 158 and State Route 256, a short hop from US Route 33
- Closer options
- Buckeye Lake and Millersport neighbors may be closer to Buckeye Lake on Hebron Rd; Lancaster residents, to North Memorial Dr
What Neighbors Are Saying
- Bleh
a month ago
Love this place. Always serve great food, the staff are all kind, the deliveries are never too long, absolutely no complains. Today I ordered for delivery and they gave me a cookie for free because of the wait! I’m not even sure if the wait was that long but the gesture is so nice! 100% recommending giving this place your business
- Dale Cooley
6 months ago
My wife and I brought our granddaughter tonight. The granddaughter is a very picky eater. She had a cheese pizza and said ‘best pizza ever!’ My wife and I also enjoyed our pizza. A customer next to us had a calzone and remarked how big it was. Staff remarked ‘we have boxes’. 😁. We will be back.
- Ginny Withrow
2 months ago
My advice would be to bake the chips on parchment paper not foil, it sticks to the foil really bad. Has to be a solution to avoid eating foil or wasting chips.
- Carla Persinger
3 years ago
We always do take out. But the pizza is tasty and their appetizers very good too. The Buffalo Chips are my favorite!!
- Margaret Green
a year ago
Cannot rate atmosphere. Delivery service was excellent! Driver called me when she didn’t get a response to the doorbell or knock on the door; I was babysitting my two little grandchildren and did not hear either of them. But between my watch and my phone in my pocket I did hear the call. Thank you, you really helped to make our evening special.
Reviews from Google
Start a Franchise
Are you ready to start your own successful business? Look no further than Creno's Pizza franchise! With a proven track record of pizza restaurants and corporate support, you can bring the taste of delicious, authentic pizza to your community while building a fantastic career.
Learn More
